Estimates and approvals

Auto Body Shop Estimate Capture Rate

How many of the estimates your auto body shop writes turn into approved repairs? Use the calculator to check your numbers, then give each undecided estimate an owner and a next step.

By AutoHound4 minute read
Explore a sample shopPrivate 7-day demo. No credit card.
The short answer

Divide the number of original estimates that became approved jobs by the original estimates written in the same group. If 18 of 30 originals have been approved, your capture rate is 60% as of the review date.

Estimate capture rate calculator

Choose a group of original estimates by the date they were written. Enter the total, then the number of those same estimates the customer has approved for repair as of your review date.

Formula: Approved original estimates ÷ original estimates written × 100. A shop with no original estimates in the period has no rate to report.

What happens to pending estimates?

Suppose your shop wrote 30 original estimates in October. At your November 6 review, 18 customers had approved the repair, seven were still deciding, and five had declined. All 30 belong in October’s count. Your capture rate to date is 18 ÷ 30 = 60%.

On November 13, three of the seven pending customers approve. The same October group now has 21 approvals out of 30, or 70%. Keep those three approvals with their October estimates. To compare two months fairly, give each group the same time to reach a decision and label the review date.

If someone reports 18 approvals out of 23 decisions, they get about 78%. That answers a different question: how often the shop won among people who already decided. It leaves seven open estimates out of sight.

Which estimates belong in the count?

  • Count one original per repair opportunity. If estimate E-104 receives two supplements, all three versions still describe one opportunity. Bring in a separate original when the customer comes back for a different repair.
  • Agree on the approval milestone. For this calculation, count the estimate once the shop records authorization to do the repair. A request for a quote, an appointment to inspect damage, or an insurer’s acknowledgment alone does not meet that definition.
  • Keep a consistent review window. Choose the original write dates first. Count approvals among those originals through one stated cutoff. Dividing all jobs approved this month by all estimates written this month can mix different groups.

CCC also uses capture rate to describe the share of estimates that turn into repair work. Record your shop’s exact approval milestone alongside the rate so a change in procedure doesn’t look like a change in performance. CCC’s definition of capture rate.

Follow up on undecided estimates

Download the editable estimate follow-up worksheet (Excel). It has a blank log for your shop and a separate completed example. Use one copy for each group of originals you plan to review. Keep the original estimate date, decision, last contact, next action, owner, and due date together.

Start with the question holding up the customer’s decision. These sample messages are for customers who have agreed to hear from your shop through that channel.

  • Estimate sent. “Hi Jo, it’s Maya at the shop. I sent the estimate for the rear bumper this morning. Did it reach you, and is there a line you’d like me to walk through?”
  • Waiting on an insurer. “Hi Jo, you mentioned you were waiting to hear from your adjuster. Has anything come through, or would it help if I sent another copy of the estimate?”
  • Timing is the obstacle. “Hi Jo, you said you’d know your work schedule today. Would you like me to check our next drop-off openings, or would a call next week work better?”

A customer who asks for a call Friday stays pending with Friday’s follow-up assigned. A customer who tells you they chose another shop can be marked declined and taken off the follow-up list. Silence alone is not a decision.

Find the estimate author in AutoHound

When comparing auto body shop software, ask the vendor to show who gets credit when one person writes an estimate and another manages the job.

In AutoHound, open Reports → Estimates and insurers → Estimate Conversion to review which original estimates became approved jobs. This report credits the estimator who wrote the original. For an import, the shop confirms its author before that estimate counts toward a staff member. Unconfirmed and external authors remain separate.

If Maya wrote the estimate and Luis later took over the repair order, Estimate Conversion credits Maya after her authorship is confirmed. Luis can use My Conversion to review original estimates on the repair orders he owns. That distinction matters when you are discussing estimating performance or assigning the next customer call. Explore AutoHound’s reports.

YOUR COLLISION WORKFLOW, CONNECTED

Try it in a demo shop

Open Estimate Conversion in the sample shop and see how original estimates are credited to their authors.